| 2018 | Cleveland State Baseball |
| 2017 | Vanderbilt Soccer and Lacrosse |
| 2016 | Lipscomb University |
| 2015 | UT Lindsay Nelson Stadium |
| 2013 | Chattanooga State Community College |
| 2012 | University of Memphis |
| 2011 | Vanderbilt University |
| 2010 | Shield Watkins Field at Neyland Stadium |
